The Great Moon Hoax

A newspaper announces extraordinary discoveries. Follow its source, examine its figures and find what can be checked.

3 synthesis scenes · 8 pieces · 15–25 min (estimate, unmeasured)

Standard difficulty · distinguish claim, test and conclusion

Enable JavaScript to continue the interactive investigation.

News from the Cape

August 1835. A press account brings New York news from the Cape of Good Hope: John Herschel has supposedly observed a living world on the Moon. The astronomer is named, the place identified and the discovery placed under the authority of a scientist observing far from his readers.

The text presents Andrew Grant as his assistant. It attributes the report to a supplement of the Edinburgh Journal of Science, a scientific periodical published in Edinburgh. Between the Cape telescope and the New York page, it thus draws a chain of transmission: a scientist, a collaborator and a specialist publication.

The expedition becomes the setting for a catalogue of landscapes, animals and creatures. Readers can follow this world in detail without leaving their newspaper. The names at the head of the account seem to bring a distant observatory within reach.

CLIPPED summary from the 1859 collected text. Several exhibits share this one account; they are not independent confirmations.

Previous story edition